Jumbo Stuffed Pepper
$7.16
Green pepper filled with chili meat, rice, Jack cheese, and salsa.
“Im obsessed with the stuffed pepper and their soups. Highly recommend!”
Warm tortillas and savory fillings shape Mexican food at Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille in Selden, NY, available for pickup.
Order onlineJumbo Stuffed Pepper
$7.16
Green pepper filled with chili meat, rice, Jack cheese, and salsa.
“Im obsessed with the stuffed pepper and their soups. Highly recommend!”
Nachos
$11.22
Crisp corn chips are topped with melted cheese and fresh salsa.
Birria Pizza
$16.99
Crispy flour tortillas hold braised beef, melted cheese, and onions.
1/2 lb. Guacamole and Chips
$9.34
Half a pound of fresh guacamole comes with crunchy golden corn chips.
Taco Birria
$11.04+
Chipotle-braised beef tacos with cheese, onion, and cilantro.
“Great food and service. I'm a regular and couldn't ask for a better local Mexican restaurant.”
Taco Carnitas (2)
$11.22
Two corn tacos hold pulled pork, onion, cilantro, guacamole and salsa.
“The food here is great real authentic. My family's favorite are the tacos carnitas”
Taco Crispy
$4.25+
Crispy corn tortilla taco with fresh toppings and chosen protein.
Taco Softie
$4.57+
A soft taco with lettuce, cheese, sour cream, salsa, and your protein choice.
Burrito Loco
$12.15+
Rice, black beans, Jack cheese, sour cream and salsa wrapped in a tortilla.
“Goto spot for local Mexican takeout. They have some tables there but I usually don't see many people eating in”
Burrito California
$12.60+
A burrito wraps meat, fries, corn, guacamole, sour cream and cheese.
“Probably the best California burrito this side of the Mississippi. Have ordered it at least 40 times.”
Burrito Vegetariano
$11.22
Rice, beans, lettuce, guacamole, salsa and Jack cheese in a tortilla.
Burrito Fajita
$12.36+
Meat, sautéed vegetables, Jack cheese, and guacamole wrapped in a tortilla.
Quesadilla
$10.00
Flour tortilla with melted jack cheese, salsa, guacamole and sour cream.
“Went there yesterday for the first time. The food was great. I had a quesadilla, special and a taco. They both were terrific. Can’t wait to go back and try other things.”
Loaded Quesadilla
$14.54
Chicken, cheeses, corn, beans, and zesty sauce fill a flour tortilla.
Buffalo Quesadilla
$13.50
Buffalo chicken quesadilla with cheese, ranch, and fresh sides.
Blackened Chicken Quesadilla
$16.83
Blackened chicken and Jack cheese folded in a flour tortilla.
Cheesy Chili Empanada
$5.19
A pastry turnover encloses chili meat and melted mozzarella cheese.
“Excellent fresh Mexican food. I usually get the chicken burrito and chicken taco.”
Buffalo Chicken Empanada
$5.19
Pulled chicken, mozzarella, and buffalo sauce fill this savory pastry.
Cheesy Chicken Empanada
$5.19
Pulled chicken and melted mozzarella fill a savory pastry turnover.
Chili Meat Empanada
$4.15
Chili meat fills a folded pastry turnover for a savory hand pie.
Rice Bowl
$13.50+
Rice, black beans, sautéed peppers and onions, cheese, and salsa.
Chipotle Rice Bowl
$13.50+
Rice with black beans, corn, lettuce, guacamole, cheese, and chipotle mayo.
Mexi Rice Bowl
$13.50+
Rice bowl with your choice of chicken, shrimp or steak and melted cheese.
Veggie Rice Bowl
$13.50
Rice with black beans, corn, sautéed vegetables, jack cheese, and salsa.
Chili Soup
$6.75
Ground beef simmers with beans, tomatoes, chiles, and cheddar.
Tortilla Soup
$6.02
Tomato, onion, pepper and cilantro soup topped with fried tortilla strips.
Mexi Chili Soup
$6.48
Chili topped with Monterey Jack, sour cream and crisp chips.
Black Bean Soup
$6.54
Black bean soup with lime, avocado, peppers, and onions.
Sopapillas
$4.46
Puffed, fried dough pastries offer a simple Mexican-style dessert.
“Best Mexican Ever!”
Churros
$2.80
Crisp, golden fried dough sticks make a classic churro dessert.
Flan
$4.46
Silky custard dessert traditionally finished with a layer of caramel.
Xangos (Cheese Cake)
$5.61
Fried cheesecake-filled pastry with a crisp, golden shell.
At Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille, Mexican food spans meat-filled burritos, corn tortilla tacos, and cheese-filled empanadas. You'll also find rice with black beans and sautéed vegetables in bowls.
Tamales come wrapped in green corn husks with beef, chicken, or pork. Enchiladas feature green tomatillo sauce and cheese, while Carne Asada Fries layer golden fries with sautéed onions and nacho cheese.
Visit us in Selden, NY for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. Breakfast Burrito wraps a fluffy three-egg scramble and melted cheese in a soft burrito, with bacon or chorizo available to add.
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.
Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille offers kid-friendly options, including Kids Chicken Fingers & French Fries and Kids Mini Quesadilla.
Explore our menu to see all the options for your next family meal.